Posts

Treaties Without Compliance: Madagascar’s Familiar Story

Image
Madagascar is a member of the African Union, COMESA, SADC and the Indian Ocean Commission. It has signed regional treaties, accepted obligations and repeatedly declared its commitment to African integration. On paper, the country is connected to a considerable regional market. In practice, however, the familiar story returns: Madagascar signs the treaty, makes the commitment and then struggles to meet the requirements. This is not simply a question of political goodwill. Regional agreements impose practical obligations. Governments must align laws, simplify customs procedures, apply rules of origin, remove unnecessary barriers and ensure that businesses can actually use the promised preferences. They must also ratify supporting protocols and implement reforms within agreed timetables. Madagascar has often fallen short. Under SADC, some related protocols remain incomplete or unratified. Under the COMESA framework, businesses continue to face administrative obstacles, customs difficultie...

Environmental Treaties: Commitments, Control and Responsibility

Image
Environmental protection is not solely a domestic issue. Through international treaties, Madagascar has accepted responsibilities concerning climate change, biodiversity, forests, wetlands and endangered species. These agreements create opportunities for international cooperation, but they also raise questions about sovereignty, enforcement and accountability. Treaty obligations accepted by Madagascar Madagascar is party to major environmental agreements, including the Paris Agreement and the Convention on Biological Diversity. It has also developed national plans for climate adaptation, biodiversity protection and emissions reduction. By 2030, Madagascar aims to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions by 28% and increase its capacity to absorb greenhouse gases by approximately 20%. These targets demonstrate that the country has established a formal policy framework. However, signing treaties and adopting national plans is only the beginning. The important question is whether these commitments...

Women and Children in Madagascar: Commitments on Paper, Protection in Practice

Image
Madagascar has signed up to many of the major international and regional agreements protecting women and children. The country has accepted important legal responsibilities. The more difficult question is whether those commitments are being translated into protection, equality and opportunity in everyday life. The answer is mixed. What Madagascar has signed up to Madagascar ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) in 1989. It also ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) in 1991. In relation to children, Madagascar has ratified the Optional Protocols concerning: - Children in armed conflict - The sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography Madagascar has also ratified the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child, as well as key International Labour Organization conventions concerning the minimum age of employment and the worst forms of child labour. These commitments are significant. The...

Human Rights and the Malagasy State

Image
International treaties establish promises. Human-rights indicators help us examine whether those promises are being delivered. Madagascar has accepted major international obligations through instruments including the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights. These commitments cover political freedoms, access to justice, equality, education, healthcare, employment and social protection. More than fifty years after ratifying the two UN Covenants, the question is no longer whether Madagascar has made international promises. The question is whether those promises have produced meaningful change. The evidence suggests that delivery remains seriously inadequate. Measuring the record Three international indicators provide a useful starting point: These measures do not capture every aspect of Malagasy life. Nor should a country’s human-rights record be reduced t...

Madagascar’s Donor Dependence: Why Foreign Relations Must Be Managed Carefully

Image
Madagascar has the right to pursue an independent foreign policy. However, independence is easier to defend when a country is financially self-reliant. Madagascar continues to depend heavily on foreign grants, concessional loans, technical assistance and debt support. This creates an important strategic reality: the country must manage its relationships carefully with the governments and institutions that help finance its development. The scale of international assistance Official Development Assistance, or ODA, includes grants and concessional loans provided by governments and international organisations to support development and welfare. The 2024 global figures illustrate the unequal distribution of development finance: OECD-DAC members therefore accounted for roughly four-fifths of the reported global total. These figures need to be interpreted carefully. The OECD-DAC figure covers countries such as the United States, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Japan, Canada, Australia an...

Madagascar’s Pension Funds: A Bailout Without Transparency?

Image
Madagascar’s 2027 initial finance bill reportedly provides for a State contribution of 448.4 billion ariary to support two public pension funds: the Caisse de Retraites Civiles et Militaires (CRCM) and the Caisse de Prévoyance et de Retraites (CPR). The reported figures are: - Own revenue: 742.2 billion ariary - Planned expenditure: 1,190.6 billion ariary - Financing gap: 448.4 billion ariary - 2026 financing gap: 459.8 billion ariary The reduction is welcome, but modest. The more important question is why these funds continue to require such substantial support from the State. What are these funds? The CRCM provides pensions for civil servants and military personnel. The CPR serves another category of public-sector employees. Both are ultimately linked to public finances, meaning that persistent deficits become a burden on taxpayers and the national budget. A State subsidy is not automatically evidence of failure. Pension systems can legitimately require government support when contri...

Diplomacy Without Embassies: Rethinking Madagascar’s Overseas Representation

Image
Why does Madagascar maintain diplomatic relations with countries where it has no resident ambassador, while those countries maintain embassies in Antananarivo? This question was recently raised by Colonel Michaël Randrianirina, president of the Refondation movement, during a meeting with members of the Malagasy diaspora in Turkey. His argument was straightforward: embassies are expensive, and Madagascar must carefully consider whether each mission produces sufficient national benefit. That is a reasonable question. Diplomacy is not free. An embassy requires premises, security, transport, administrative support and salaries. The ambassador’s salary is only one part of the cost. In a country with limited public resources, every overseas mission must be judged against competing priorities at home, including education, healthcare, infrastructure and public administration. However, the value of an embassy cannot be measured only by immediate financial returns. Diplomacy is about interests A...